Toji’s OpenGL 3 Tutorials

OpenGL is Dead

August 12th, 2008

So… Where to begin?

For a while now we’ve been hearing spectacular things about what OpenGL 3.0 was supposed to be. It was going to be a COMPLETE re-write of the API, focusing on an all new object-based model and scraping the cruft off the spec that has been accumulating over the years. Things like the fixed function pipeline, immediate mode, etc. were going to be banished in favor of a streamlined, easy-to-use, easy-to-implement set of core functions. It was also going to bring the API up to modern standards, incorporating all of the great new features of DirectX 10, but without the massive barrier to entry called Vista. And, in fact, I and many other developers beleived that it could easily change the tide of the 3D wars: If GL3 exposed all of the functionality of DX10 but didn’t require the largely shunned OS, as well as having an easy to use interface, it could have very quickly become the Game developers API of choice!

I put together this (admittedly humble) site in anticipation of just that. My desire was to, as soon as possible once the spec was out, produce a series of code sample that would show how to produce the same results in both GL2.1 and the radically different GL3.0, so that hobby developers could have some simple examples of how to port their existing functionality. I still wish I COULD do that, but sadly I’m here to tell you that there’s simply no point anymore.

The official OpenGL 3.0 spec was released today, after months and months of delays. You can go check out the link, but frankly don’t get too excited. I jumped on it the moment I saw the link show up in my RSS feed. I couldn’t start reading fast enough… and then I saw the document start mentioning glVertex3f().

My heart fell. I literally felt sick to my stomach. My mind swirled to justify it: Why in the world would immediate mode still be in the GL3 specs? The more I read, the more it became apparent that what I was reading was not at all a brand shiny new spec, but instead a repackaging of all that came before with about 2 pages (yes, only 2) worth new content tacked onto the end in the form of a few NVidia extensions that had been promoted to core.

Yes. You read that right. OpenGL 3, the savior of cross platform graphics, the “Totally re-written API”, is nothing but a few new functions and a vague notion of depreciating older functions down the road. My eagerly awaited object model was nowhere to be found. To say I was a bit unhappy is an understatement.
My visits to several community forms confirmed that I wasn’t alone in my “unhappiness”. Developers from all over were voicing my exact thoughts on the matter: We were left in the dark, lied to, and given a end-product that frankly looked as if nobody cared. Not even Vista was this big of a slap in the face. A few people have pointed to a new extension (written against 2.1, mind you) that looks as if it may be used to implement part of the new object model that was talked about, saying that this could possibly help things along, but when compared to what people really wanted, it’s pretty weak sauce. We’re promised a fully re-written, modern graphics API and given an extension which MIGHT be used to implement SOME of what was expected IF anyone supports it. Forgive me if I’m unipressed.
So here’s what it’s come down to: Microsoft has been making measurable strides in the progression of their graphics API, while OpenGL promised big and barely lurched forward. While I don’t like the platform lock-in of DirectX, the fact is that it’s a very good API that has some solid leadership behind it, and while I consider the fact that it’s latest iteration is Vista only a misstep, it’s not nearly as big of a disaster as what KHRONOS has done with the one and only viable competitor.

A little while ago, distracted from this site by a lack of news about the API, I started a new personal game project. I fiddled with OpenGL for a while, but realized after a while that I was just wrapping the calls up into an interface that looked an awful lot like Direct3D. I didn’t have any intents on making the project cross platform just yet, so I switched APIs, telling myself all the while that I would go back to OpenGL when 3.0 came out. Problem is, I have no reason to anymore. There’s nothing compelling in GL3 for a developer in my position. DirectX is simply a better API, and as long as you only care about Windows (80%+ of the gaming market) there’s no reason to even try using OpenGL anymore. And what’s more: I don’t intend to ever switch back. I’ve waited patiently for nearly two years now only to be lied to and dissapinted. My faith in KHRONOS is gone, and no amount of promises will bring it back. And I think that I’m not the only one who feels like that. The whole situation saddens me, but I can’t do a thing about it.

So no, there’s never going to be any OpenGL3.0 tutorials on this site, even though that was it’s sole purpouse. There’s just no point: It’s really just 2.1 with extras. on top of that, I refuse to waste my time promoting an API that has effectively given me and many other developers the finger.
Congrats, Microsoft. Direct3D won. OpenGL is dead, killed by an owner who quite simply didn’t care.

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments »

OpenGL 3 delayed

October 31st, 2007

So today the Khronos group announced that the OpenGL 3 spec was *Gasp!* Not done! One would imagine that the fact that we don’t have it yet would be indication enough of that, but I suppose it’s nice to be all official about it…

In all seriousness, though, the announcement was made in this thread on the OpenGL forums and the reasons cited are simply that they don’t want to release a flawed product. To quote the thread:

Rest assured we are working as hard as we can on getting the specification done. The ARB meets 5 times a week, and has done so for the last two months, to get this out to you as soon as possible. Getting a solid specification put together will also help us with the follow-ons to OpenGL 3: OpenGL Longs Peak Reloaded and Mount Evans. We don’t want to spend time fixing mistakes made in haste.

Hey, sounds good to me. If I have to wait a few extra months now to prevent years of frustration and cursing later I’ll gladly do it! But this also raises the question of what’s going to happen with this site in the mean time. After all the title IS Toji’s OpenGL 3 tutorials, and I probably won’t have many of those if I don’t have an OpenGL 3 to work with.

Well, I’m certainly not content to sit around and wait so I’ve decided to backtrack on my original plans a bit. First off, while I still intend to pair the existing to tutorial code with it’s OpenGL 3 equivalent when I can I’ve decided that in the mean time I’m going to flesh out the tutorials I have a little bit more, add some new ones, and actually start to add some tutorial text to go along with it. While the title of the site won’t change, until the spec is ready I intend to turn this page into a full-fledged OpenGL 2.1 tutorial site.

Along those lines, I plan on adding at least one more tutorial about image quality settings such as FSAA, Anisotropic Filtering, and Vsync, and adding a non-tutorial code sample for creating an OpenGL Screensaver. Once those are up and I’ve had a chance to add some tutorial text, I’ll then actually start promoting the site on various other development sites to start getting feedback from other developers. Hopefully this will mean that by the time the GL3 spec DOES roll out (which will probably be Dec 07/Jan 08) the tutorials that we are converting will be rock-solid!

Wish me luck!

Tags: Announcement, Delay, Progress
Posted in News | 1 Comment »

Tutorials

October 4th, 2007

A list of each OpenGL 3 Tutorial by category

Core Concepts

Tutorial 01 - OpenGL Window: [2.1]
Tutorial 02 - Drawing Geometry: [2.1]
Tutorial 03 - Matrices: [2.1]
Tutorial 04 - Indexed Geometry: [2.1]
Tutorial 05 - Texture Mapping: [2.1]
Tutorial 06 - Multitexture: [2.1]
Tutorial 07 - Render to Texture: [2.1]

Shader Techniques

Coming Soon

3rd Party Libraries & Utilities

Coming Soon

Posted in News | 4,078 Comments »

Tutorial 07 - Render to Texture [2.1]

October 3rd, 2007

[SOURCE, BIN - Win32] 07 - Render to Texture (2.1).zip

Rendering a scene to a texture which can then be bound and rendered itself

Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: Framebuffer Objects, Render Targets, Render to Texture
Posted in Core Concepts, Tutorials | 8,410 Comments »

Tutorial 06 - Multitexture [2.1]

October 3rd, 2007

[SOURCE, BIN - Win32] 06 - Multitexture (2.1).zip

Binding multiple textures at a time and blending them together in a shader

Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: blending, Multitexture
Posted in Core Concepts, Tutorials | 1 Comment »

Tutorial 05 - Texture Mapping [2.1]

October 3rd, 2007

[SOURCE, BIN - Win32] 05 - Texture Mapping (2.1).zip

The key to just about every modern graphics technique out there, texture mapping gives flat surfaces, well, texture! Also covered is linear, bilinear, and trilinear filtering.

Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: Texture, TGA
Posted in Core Concepts, Tutorials | 2 Comments »